PDA

View Full Version : John gospel question; "In the beginning" who (diegetical said this? John the Baptist?


Enda80
July 30, 2005, 06:09 AM
I have seen many people, when asked where Jesus claimed to be the same entity as Yahweh, reference the prologue to the Gospel of John "In the Beginning was the word..."

However, the Gospel of John does not present this as a saying of Jesus. It seem unclear who said it. I had though maybe John the Baptist (diagetically) said it, because he appears in the next paragraph.

Toto
July 30, 2005, 06:03 PM
I have seen many people, when asked where Jesus claimed to be the same entity as Yahweh, reference the prologue to the Gospel of John "In the Beginning was the word..."

However, the Gospel of John does not present this as a saying of Jesus. It seem unclear who said it. I had though maybe John the Baptist (diagetically) said it, because he appears in the next paragraph.

When introducing a new vocabulary word, it helps to spell it correctly, so the audience can look it up:

Diegesis (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diegesis) In diegesis the author tells the story. He is the narrator himself who presents to the audience or the readership his or his characters' thoughts and all that is in his or their imagination, their fantasies and dreams.

I see nothing to connect John 1:1 to John the Baptist, myself.

sharon45
July 30, 2005, 09:56 PM
I see nothing to connect John 1:1 to John the Baptist, myself.
Agreed. I see it as a christian reworking of the beginnings of Genesis with humankind given another chance at 'bat', told by a supposedly inspired writer.