PDA

View Full Version : talking to children about death.


Rushianbeing
August 26, 2003, 08:59 AM
Hi there y'all, I need some suggestions and figured this was one of the best places to ask for this sort of help.

Two years ago (today, as a matter of fact), my sister in law died suddenly and completely unexpectedly. We are not certain what caused her death, the autopsy was very intensive but inconclusive, and the only thing the docs could come up with was that she likely had something like Wolff Parkinson White syndrome, where some cells in her heart are abnormal and misfired, causing the electrical signals to stop and her heart to stop beating. She was 31 years old, and so incredibly loved by all of us, especially my little brother (her husband). We were devastated beyond description, and obviously none of us will ever be the same. But we are grownups, and we handle it as best we can.

The issue is, when Lena died, she had just given birth to a beautiful daughter (my niece Maya) 11 weeks earlier. Maya obviously does not remember her mother, and has been extremely well taken care of since Lena's death by my parents, who moved her and my brother in with them, then relocated to Charleston to continue to raise her with my brother. She does not lack for love and attention, and she is a beautiful, perfect, well-adjusted little girl. But she is just past two years old now, and is starting to grasp the concept of Mommy. It is only a matter of time before she starts to ask questions. She is still very young, but is hyperintelligent (this is according to her docs as well, so it's not just us being biased! Okay, maybe just a little. ;) ). Does anyone have any ideas or know of any resources out there that would help guide us in explaining Lena's death to Maya? We do not want her to be scared of death, or be afraid that she's not going to wake up when she goes to sleep...things like that. We are non-theists and obviously would feel like we were lying to her if we told her Mommy's in the Christian Heaven, but sometimes I think what would be the harm in telling her this? I just don't want her to be afraid. This is doubly difficult because the docs theorize that what killed Maya's mother is genetic and runs in her family (the same thing happened with Lena's grandmother, she died suddenly at age 36), so Maya will have to be periodically checked out to make sure she is okay (she already had one EKG at 6 months old and looked fine). This is obviously going to scare her to death.

I realize that we cannot avoid scaring Maya, and that she is going to feel sad and frightened and confused no matter what, but we want to minimize it as much as we can. Any suggestions would be greatly, greatly appreciated.

Thanks guys...

Rushian

sugarbeth
August 26, 2003, 04:19 PM
I recently got a book for my daughter called "Lifetimes", which I like. It puts things very simply that one is born, one dies, and in between is their lifetime.

Another one that I'm waiting for is, "The Dead Bird" by the author of Goodnight Moon. It's also non-religious.

jayh
August 26, 2003, 08:30 PM
I seriously think much of childrens distress at death (other than the direct loss of someone... not the case here) is feeling the tension in the adults, sensing that the adults are very distressed and trying to hide something terrible.

She's not going to know about genetic links, there is no reason that need be mentioned at this point. A visit to the doctor is simply that.

Children often don't think anything like that will happen to them, so it's the adults that can put that fear into their minds. I can remember deaths (great grandfather etc at about 5, and a playmate who got leukemia at about 7). I don't remember being all that stressed over it.

j

RalphyS
August 27, 2003, 07:29 AM
I often wondered about this dilemma, how to explain the atheistic view to children.

I think being truthfull and to tell them we are born, we live and we die and we don't have any power of that in general is the best way. Telling them a fairytale about heaven will only lead to more questions and suddenly God is in the picture.

I don't know what happened is also an answer, I feel it's better to state that than to tell lies (=beautiful fantasies) to your children.

I think it will amaze you at how a child will cope with the truth.

I think it also has to do with your own perspective on death, do you think death is something to fear? What is the use of fearing death it is simply unavoidable, what is important is what you do with your life.

Ofcourse a nice smoochy touch (but therefore not untrue) is stating that the deceased loved one will always live on in the hearts of everything who was touched by her during her life.

Sure, God and heaven are nice and easy when confronted with death or disease and such, but nice and easy is not what life and death is and you shouldn't create a pretend world for children, the best preparation of adulthood is a confrontation with the (sometimes harsh) truth. And if she's so intelligent, she will apreciate and understand your honesty all the more.

frostymama
August 27, 2003, 07:52 AM
I was just honest with my oldest. He started asking questions at around 2 1/2 years old. We used to go on walks together to the park and we would sometimes see dead plants, bugs, or birds. I just used his curiosity over them to help explain that is simply a part of life. The realization that he would die (and I would a well) didn't come until he was almost 4. There were a few tears over that, but they didn't last long.

When we had a family member doing poorly in the ICU a year ago I did look for some books on illness. I ran across a lot of age appropriate stuff on death. You will probably have to dig a bit to avoid angels and heaven, but I did see a few that would work (sadly I don't remember which ones).

Good luck. :)