PDA

View Full Version : The heretic's Heretic.


Tyler Durden
April 3, 2004, 04:43 AM
A sixteenth century Dominican monk who happened to be also a philosopher, Giovan Domenico Campanella was a model heretic who was a daring thinker during adverse conditions, and played the game according to his rules. After becoming disgruntled with Aristotelianism, Campanella found the empiricist Bernardino Teleso to be the better alternative. The claims that knowledge is essentially sensation, that our cognitive ability was merely the collection of distinct chunks of information only gained Teleso's books a ticket to the Index of Forbidden Books. Campanella, also in the spirit of Epicurus, dismissed the supernatural concepts of miracles, heaven, hell, and declared that these were superstitions circulated by the Church to sedate the people into a rather harmless lot. By 1592 the Dominican cranked out a Philosophia Sensibus Demonstrata, Philosophy demonstrated by the Senses. Once the Spanish Inquisition caught wind of these ambiguously atheistic claims, they introduced Campanella to the slammer. After six years, he was confined to a monastery in Naples.

Campanella became embroiled in the political controversy over the legitimacy of the Spanish domination in south Italy, and the Italian Inquisition didn’t like the stench of utopia from his ideas. Consequently, they returned Campanella to prison, but this time with the attendant medieval age means of conditioning: la veglia, a unforgettable torture.

Given the fact that heretics were executed, instead of submitting Campanella decided to feign madness. The tortures continued until the sentence was changed to lifetime, and Campanella spent the first four years chained to a wall in a dungeon. Despite this handicap he still wrote. The Hispanic Monarchy was an guidebook on how a king of Spain actualizes the divine right of Spain to control the world.

This pleased those in power that in 1626, six years after publication, the Pope “pardoned� Campanella. Five years later, to demonstrate his gratitude, Campanella penned Atheismus triumphatus or Atheism Conquered a polemic on freethinkers such as the Machiavellians or Calvinists and other heretics. The beliefs of these sophists were presented and countered with the arguments of the supremacy of the Catholic Church. Seems like a pragmatic kiss ass, aye?

Actually, those freethinkers were depicted with such vigor and lucidity, whereas the orthodox were characterized by clichés, tired platitudes and feeble rationalizations. The Catholics couldn’t really complain because Campanella had presented their very arguments!

In time, the book became an underground favorite among the libertines and other atheists in closet.
:notworthy:

Vorkosigan
April 3, 2004, 08:19 AM
Thanks Tyler! What are your sources? Is there a bio of this fella?

Vorkosigan

Tyler Durden
April 3, 2004, 01:29 PM
Sources: Robert Greene, a classics scholar
Bio: do a google search and you will find plenty of short summaries, but i have yet to see any that expanded on the actual contents of Atheism Conquered. :(

Tyler Durden
April 3, 2004, 01:34 PM
Here is a short exposition. (http://radicalacademy.com/philcampanella.htm)

buddahead
April 3, 2004, 01:42 PM
{Deleted}

Postcard73
April 3, 2004, 05:20 PM
I could be wrong, but I think this thread might be better off in PA&SA since it is about an influential atheist and one of the links discusses his philosophy.

Scott (Postcard73)
GRD Moderator

Al Kafirun
April 5, 2004, 02:55 AM
Hey, cool! I've never heard of him. I got a new hero.